On Fiscal Policy:
Barack Obama clearly won the first portion of the debate. John McCain tried to make it a “class warfare” issue and tried to play the socialism card. However, Obama clearly debunked McCain’s claims by pointing out that over 95% of small businesses make less than $250,000 and that is where the most jobs are created.
John McCain repeated the misleading statement about Ireland’s 11% tax rate. Yes, they may have that tax rate, but do they have the same loopholes for the wealthy? This is something McCain leaves out.
What will you cut because of the current economic crisis:
Obama will cut programs, line by line, in order to save money to pay for his programs. He would invest in energy programs that will prevent us from having to borrow money from China to send it to Saudi Arabia.
McCain brought up the lie that Obama is against drilling, which he is not. McCain said he would have a spending freeze, which some have labeled as him using a hatchet. McCain defended his stance by saying that he would use a hatchet and then use a scalpel. Um, if you use the hatchet, the scalpel is kinda useless don’t you think?
McCain would also fight for a line item veto. Apparently McCain doesn’t remember the Supreme Court ruling stating that the line item veto violates the Constitution.
McCain brought up earmarks that he would cut and veto. However, as Obama pointed out, earmarks are a very small part of the federal budget.
McCain also brought up the bill that Obama voted for that contained “goodies” for oil companies. I guess McCain forgets that when it came to adding those “goodies” to the legislation, Obama voted against them. Obama only voted for the main bill that he supported that unfortunately contained some provisions he didn’t like.
Setting the tone of the campaign:
McCain blamed Obama for failing to do a series of town hall debates for the reason that the debate took an ugly turn. Who is he trying to fool? That answer was just pathetic.
McCain complained that Obama did not repudiate the claims made by another elected Democrat. Did McCain repudiate the claims that Obama pals around with terrorists when Sarah Palin made her claim? Of course not!
McCain then brought up public financing and Obama’s changing his mind about accepting it. I have a video about that here. Basically, Republicans are against government handouts but they criticize Obama for refusing to accept a government handout. It is sheer hypocrisy.
McCain said that attacks on his healthcare plan are an attack ad. Being critical of POLICY is not an example of an attack ad. If this campaign only contained criticisms of policy then we would be in a much better place. But McCain runs ad like this and this, hardly criticisms of Obama’s policy. They are personal attacks and the kind of vindictive attacks that the American public are sick of.
McCain said that Obama falsely claims that McCain is against federal funding for stem cell research. McCain IS against federal funding for embryonic stem cell research, and that is Obama’s point.
McCain then went on to make personal attacks against Obama by questioning his relationship with Ayers and ACORN. Obama’s response blew McCain out of the water.
“The fact that this has become such an important part of your campaign Senator McCain says more about your campaign that it says about me”
McCain kept on digging himself deeper and deeper. If anything loses McCain this election, this may very well be it. I think McCain basically scuttled the ship that is his campaign there. He came off looking very desperate.
Why would the country be better off if your running mate became president?:
If anyone really needs to hear the candidates explain this, you are not paying attention to this election. Sarah Palin is absolutely unqualified to be Vice President.
By what specific percentage will you reduce our reliance on foreign oil in your first term?:
Obama gave a timeframe of 10 years to eliminate our reliance on middle eastern oil. McCain failed to list a number of years or a percentage in his first term.
The discussion got to free trade. Well, Obama is against unfair trade agreements that don’t take into account fair labor laws. If one country lacks the labor laws that we have, that puts our workers at a disadvantage. Clearly Obama has it right on trade.
Would you control healthcare costs over expanding healthcare coverage?:
This one is really simple. Obama’s healthcare plan both expands coverage and reduces costs. I have a video comparing the two plans here. By providing preventive care, we will reduce costs and increase coverage.
McCain continued the lie that Obama will fine “Joe the plumber” for not providing healthcare. If you go to Barack Obama’s website, he clearly states that small businessmen (like “Joe the plumber”) wont pay any fines and that he will provide tax credits to those businesses who do provide healthcare. And when Obama said “zero”, McCain looked like a deer in headlights, and this also might be a moment that loses McCain this election.
McCain also said that Obama’s plan is a “single payer system” which is absolutely false. Single payer systems do not allow people to have their own plans.
Roe v. Wade and judicial litmus tests:
McCain rejects a litmus test, will only appoint Supreme Court justices who are qualified, but he doesn’t believe that anyone who supports the ruling of Roe v Wade is qualified. How about that for spin… he won’t have a litmus test unless he does.
Obama believes women are in the best position to make that decision, that there is a right to privacy in the Constitution, and that States should not be able to ignore that right to privacy via state referendum. Obama also brought up the Ledbetter case. We are absolutely on the same page.
Obama clearly stated that he would be against all late term abortions as long as the bill contained provisions to help the woman save her life or health. I am in 100% agreement with him. And I would personally add that anyone who would prevent a woman from saving her life… is a monster.
Obama then went on to discuss the desire of reasonable people on both sides of the abortion debate to reduce the number of abortions that take place. Democrats added that to their platform this year. What Obama forgot to mention was that the Republican’s eliminated that from their platform this year as well. Republicans eliminated the goal to reduce abortions and only kept the desire to make a law punishing people for getting them. How sad is that?
Conclusion:
McCain clearly lost this debate. McCain made part of his attacks in this debate on Obama’s eloquance (is that akin to him saying that Obama is so well spoken?). From his continued foolish personal attacks on Obama during the question on if you could clean up this campaign to his “deer in the headlights” look when Obama said that the fine “Joe the Plumber” would pay is “zero” fines for failing to provide healthcare, he just lost. Period.
Now, Obama came off as Presidential. He fended off McCain’s personal attacks. He correted McCain’s lies. He was just better tonight and clearly won this debate. Now, if you want another reason to vote for Obama, ask Republican Dick Luger who endosed Obama’s approach to diplomacy by saying:
He correctly cautions against the implication that hostile nations must be dealt with almost exclusively through isolation or military force… In some cases, refusing to talk can even be dangerous
I couldn’t have said it better myself.